Skip to main content

✦ Legend ✦

The Dowry Gold of Saint Nicholas

Nicholas of MyraEarliest source: c. 700 or 814-842 (dating disputed); Nicholas lived in the 4th century
Saint Nicholas Providing Dowries, Bicci di Lorenzo, c. 1433-1435Bicci di Lorenzo, Metropolitan Museum of Art, CC0
Painting of Saint Nicholas, in bishop's robes, handing bags of gold coins through a window to a poor father inside a house at night while his three daughters look on
Saint Nicholas Providing Dowries, Bicci di Lorenzo, c. 1433-1435Bicci di Lorenzo, Metropolitan Museum of Art, CC0

As the oldest telling of the story has it, a nobleman in Nicholas’s home city who had once lived in comfort fell into such poverty that he saw no way to provide dowries for his three daughters. Without a dowry, none of them could marry - and the father, in despair, began to consider a fate for his daughters he could hardly bear to name.

Nicholas - the young man who would grow up to become the 4th-century bishop of Myra behind the Santa Claus legend - was already known for his quiet generosity when he heard of the family’s plight. He wanted no credit for what he did next, so he waited until nightfall before he acted.

Under cover of darkness, Nicholas crept to the window of the man’s house and tossed in a small bag of gold coins, then hurried away before anyone saw him. In the morning, the father found the gold and could hardly believe it - enough, at last, for his eldest daughter’s dowry. The wedding was arranged, and the family’s gratitude turned to God, though no one knew whom to thank.

Nicholas returned a second time, just as quietly, with a second bag of gold for the second daughter. Again he fled before he could be seen - but this time, the father was watching for him. Determined to learn the identity of his family’s benefactor, the father kept watch each night after that.

When Nicholas came a third time, the father recognized him at once and ran out to catch him before he could slip away. Nicholas, embarrassed to have been found out, begged the man to tell no one what he had done. The father agreed, and kept the secret, though in time the story got out all the same.

How this story changed over time

Like most legends that circulate for centuries before anyone writes them down, the dowry-gold story was never told just one way. One variation in particular is worth knowing, because it explains something people still do today.

The chimney version. In some retellings, the third delivery doesn’t go as smoothly as the first two. By then it’s winter, and the family has shuttered their windows against the cold - so Nicholas has to find another way in. He climbs to the roof and drops the gold down the chimney instead, where it happens to land in a stocking the daughter had hung by the fire to dry. This detail is the thread historians most often point to when tracing the origin of hanging stockings at Christmas.

This variant does not change the heart of the story - a desperate father, three daughters, and a young man who wanted no thanks for his generosity. But it shows how a single legend can grow new branches to explain whatever a later audience needed explained, such as a chimney full of stockings.

Related on this site