Skip to main content

✦ Relic & Legend ✦

The Holy Lance

Veneration RelicSaint Peter's Basilica / Hofburg Imperial Treasury / Mother Cathedral of Holy Etchmiadzin
The Holy Lance of the Imperial Regalia, Hofburg Imperial Treasury, ViennaRené Hanke, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
The Vienna Holy Lance, an iron spearhead bound in gold and silver wire, displayed in the Imperial Treasury
The Holy Lance of the Imperial Regalia, Hofburg Imperial Treasury, ViennaRené Hanke, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

John’s Gospel records that after Christ died on the cross, a soldier pierced his side to confirm it. Later tradition gave that soldier a name, Longinus, and turned his spear into one of the most sought-after relics in Christendom. The trail is quiet for the first several centuries, but by around 530 a short pilgrim guide to Jerusalem already mentions the lance, and around 570 a pilgrim from Piacenza saw it among the Passion relics on Mount Zion - alongside, intriguingly, the Crown of Thorns.

From Jerusalem the story splits, and splits again, until three different treasuries each hold what they call the Holy Lance.

Three lances, one wound

The Vatican’s lance, kept beneath the dome of Saint Peter’s Basilica, traces its documented history furthest back toward those 6th-century Jerusalem accounts. It reached Rome by an unusual route: in 1492, the Ottoman Sultan Bayezid II sent it to Pope Innocent VIII as a diplomatic gift. The gift was part of a bargain to keep the Sultan’s exiled brother and rival claimant safely in papal custody.

Vienna’s lance tells a different story. Bound in a gold sleeve for centuries, it traveled as part of the Imperial Regalia of the Holy Roman Empire, carried out for coronation after coronation. A medieval inscription once identified a nail set into the blade as one of the nails of the Crucifixion, layering one relic tradition on top of another. Modern metallurgical study dates the blade itself to roughly the 7th to early 9th century - not a 1st-century Roman weapon, but a genuinely old and genuinely venerated one.

The third claimant, the Geghard held at Etchmiadzin in Armenia, comes with its own apostolic origin story: tradition says the Apostle Thaddeus brought it to Armenia during his first-century mission. That account is first recorded in the 12th century, and the earliest text to name the relic itself is a 13th-century Armenian manuscript - a gap of more than a thousand years.

None of the three claims can be proven, and none of the three has needed proof to draw pilgrims. As with the Holy Tunic, the Holy Lance’s real story may be less about which blade touched Christ’s side and more about how many different communities needed, across the centuries, to feel close to that moment.